Russia and China’s Veto

February 5, 2012 By Malcolm Blair-Robinson

The West is now busy blaming Russia and China for the violence in Syria, because they vetoed a not very good UN resolution. That is ridiculous.

Russia is a faded superpower, but it is no longer fading. It has not yet made the transition from military strength to economic strength, but it will get there. China is now an economic superpower, maybe the economic superpower. Neither considers the open pluralist democracy, favoured by the West, the best way to govern and they could point to the political polarisation in the US and the inability of the Eurozone to put decisions into effect, as evidence to support their conclusion. Neither is remotely equivalent to their structure in the cold war era; both populations culturally prefer constant, strong and predictable leadership to the vociferous debate of the most open democracies.

Russia and China look at Syria and see bloodshed and mayhem, but they do not see the vestige of a coherent alternative government (unlike Libya, where their opposition to western intervention was much more muted) and, post Iraq, will be sensitive of anything which looks like a policy of regime change. They might go along with regime change if there were a coherent regime in waiting, to change to. Both follow a much more nuanced approach to foreign policy than the West led by the US. Putin has described the US as a hyper-power constantly over-reaching itself. This is harsh, but their is a vestige of truth in it.

Afghanistan is a disaster to anyone willing to be realistic, Pakistan is seriously destabilised, Iraq is one of the most dangerous places for innocent civilians in the world. Moreover Iraq’s  Shia majority is allied to Iran, the direct opposite of US aims at the start of the invasion.  The Israel/Palestinian problem is no nearer resolution than it was fifty years ago. This is not a good foreign policy inventory.

Maybe it would be a good plan to see what Russia and China can do in Syria, if anything. Meanwhile before we get too critical it might be good to remember that without China’s money the US is bust and without Russia’s energy most of Europe would freeze to death.