Iraq Pull Out

The top Iraqi General has said he would like U.S troops to stay another twenty years. This is clearly impossible, although I am sure there are elemnts in the Pentagon who would love it.

What the General’s comments underline is the chronic instability of the Iraqi State as a viable, self sustaining structure, able to stand by consensus and cooperation among its people. Most of its history, from inception, has either been the exploitative, though fair, administration of the British Empire or the Sunni dominated regime of Saddam Hussein and the Ba’athists. Neither of these administrative systems was concensual. Both imposed discipline and order at the cost of freedoms, which are today described as human rights. There is no doubt that Saddam’s regime was brutal and favoured Sunnis over Shiites and Kurds.

There can be no  prediction of how this is going to end, whether Iraq will survive as a single state, whether it or its successor components will be democratic or whether there will be civil war. All we can say is that the security situation appears ominous, the democracy seems unable to pass the key test of producing a government and  more bloodshed is certain.

In this condition of current affairs, any judgement overall must be unreliable. However as the combat troops prepare to leave, let us not forget the aim of the mission. It was to effect regime change and establish a ‘beacon of democracy’ to bring peace across the Middle East. Oh yes, and to get at those weapons of mass destruction. Judged in the terms of aim versus outcome, it ranks as one of the greatest political and military failures in history.

8 Responses to “”

  1. fatburners says:

    Superbly composed opinion, thanks mate!

  2. Thank you for dropping that link… but unluckily it seems to be down? Anybody have a mirror?

  3. This article was really nicely created, and it also includes numerous helpful facts. I valued your expert manner of composing this article. You have created it is simple for me to understand.

  4. Very helpful reading. I appreciate your effort, finally a decent website with good information in it.

  5. Whether you are a organization traveller or on a prolonged family vacation, if you are staying in a single location for much more than a handful of days serviced apartments are excellent. Serviced rentals are less costly than motels and for that reason make medium to long stays much more reasonably priced. Many companies are switching to serviced apartments to residence personnel on global assignments due to the fact of the benefits they present in conditions of price and worker satisfaction. Vacation travellers on medium to extended stays are also changing to fully-serviced Wichita Apartments as not only do they supply economic financial savings, freedom and solitude, they also supply facilities and solutions that exceed all those supplied by resorts. These apartments are especially useful for couples, families, and people travelling in teams.

  6. Howdy – I should say, I?m happy with your site. I had no issues navigating via all the tabs and the info was very simple to access. I discovered what I required in no time at all. Pretty awesome.

  7. admin says:

    Merci Bien, mon ami!

  8. Bonjour, Super blog ! Je traite du m?me sujet sur mon wordpress. Je me permettrai de m?inspirer de votre texte. En vous citant bien sur et si vous le permettez. Je parle aussi de sujet comme batterie iphone 3g ou comme r4i. Merci, Ethan

Leave a Reply