Blog 2023 Malcolm Blair-Robinson

There is something very serious happening in America. It is not just to do with money, although money is the catalyst. It is to do with democracy and government. It is not to do with government at every level. Democracy is the engine of almost every strata of public administration and leadership at State and local level and it works very well. What does not work any longer is Federal government. It was set up by people who could not agree either its function or its reach, who settled on a compromise which is so full of checks and balances that only if one party is in the majority in all its institutions can it function. This produced turmoil initially ending in civil war. Lincoln established the Washington government as the power in the land, but without reform of its instruments. These are now unable to cope with the complexity of a modern state in a globalised world.

Thus there is dysfunction, which the world sees with far sharper clarity than the United States herself, causing paralysis of decision and arbitrary outcomes. The world does not like what it sees and thinks less of America because of it. The most powerful man in the world is it seems no such thing. Only in foreign policy does he yet have the power to act, leaving the impression that unable to do much at home, the President, whoever it is, turns to meddling abroad. Even here Presidents prove powerless in the one place where it counts the most; forcing peace and reason upon the Israelis to give the Palestinians a fair deal and making the Palestinians accept it. The world watches in frustration as the Israeli lobby in the US hobbles any President who dares to try and step out of its line.

Set against this serious challenge to the way America runs itself, are the financial measures thus far passed into law this year. Both have merit; Obama’s tax increases and the current cuts. Both are going to have to be repeated many times over if revenues and expenditure are to be brought into line, which is an essential requirement before the mountain of debt can be tackled. Of all these measures, the cuts to the Pentagon’s over blown budget may well do more to help America forward than anything else. The massive over-spend on defence not only de-stabilises a world which is now less focused on military power and much more concentrated on economic clout but will, unless checked, prove to be the undoing of America’s power, influence and well being. Ironically this is exactly what brought the Soviet Union down.

Not because of ill health surely? Ill health and slowly dying more or less in public are an ancient feature of the papacy. This is perfectly natural in a religion primarily concerned with life after death, which preaches its availability to all, or to all who believe and behave in the ante-chamber of life on earth. Paedophilia, theft, fraud, jealousy, cruelty, abuse, intolerance and denying the means of safe sex to prevent the spread of a terrible disease, are just a few of the behaviours regarded in the world outside the Roman Catholic Church as depraved, shocking and wicked. Most are crimes.

Yet these are the activities which define the modern Catholic church and its secretive Vatican state. Neither the organisation nor the verities it preaches can any longer be regarded as good or right or worthy, if founded upon such a breakdown of the integrity of thought and deed. The Pope remarked, as he explained his decision to step down, that it was as if the Lord were sleeping.

The Pope stood down because he lost his faith, not perhaps in God, but in the Church he headed any longer being a worthy instrument of divine will. In truth Benedict feared that God had walked away. Maybe in resigning he signalled his intention to follow Him. It will be up to his successor to organise a grand reconstruction in order to get them both to come back.

To fight a mid-term bye-election as a government party is difficult. To fight when the sitting MP resigned and is awaiting sentence for a crime is very difficult. To fight when, on top of all that, the headquarters of the party is engulfed in a sleazy scandal involving sex and the abuse of women, when it is thought to have been run by angels and saints, is very difficult indeed. To fight, and in spite of all that, to win is a major political achievement. It is a triumph for the Lib Dem activists who remained steady under fire and it is a triumph for their party leader who remained focussed under a media onslaught. The Liberal Democrats have much to celebrate today.

So has UKIP. As their leader put it, to come second and beat the Conservatives into third place is, for UKIP, a win. The thrill it gives UKIP members up and down the country, will be as nothing beside the shock wave it sends through the Tories. The maths for Cameron are clear. His party, torn asunder by an unbridgeable gap between its pro and anti EU wings, cannnot easily capture Lib Dem seats now that Europe has been brought centre stage and it cannot capture them at all if UKIP is in the fray, as it will be, for sure, after Eastleigh. This means the Tories will not win a majority in 2015.

Labour will be disappointed at its performance, although realistically it was never in the race. They had a weak candidate who said silly things, but it would have made little difference if they had fielded a savvy political staffer. This was always a three way fight between the coalition partners and the rising star of UKIP. As it happens UKIP  probably had the best and most presentable candidate.

Today the pundits will pore over the figures, extrapolate trends and project finite answers to an infinite puzzle. None of it will mean much because as always in politics, it is the unknowns of tomorrow that rule. Two things are becoming clear. The public are bored with the media obsession with sex scandals and split political parties, like split ships, sink.